| 2009 : | Geoffrey A. Bernard |
| 2008 : | Geoffrey A. Bernard |
| 2007 : | John Robert Terminello |
| 2006 : | John Robert Terminello |
| 2005 : | *** |
| 2004 : | David Calhoun Cole |
| 2003 : | Turner Watkins "Butch" Hodges |
| 2002 : | Everett Lamar "Buddy" Paulk, Jr ** |
| 2001 : | Bradley Keith "Brad" Toy * |
| 2000 : | Richard Christie "Rick" Longenecker |
| 1999 : | Ronald Walker "Ron" Ladd * |
| 1998 : | Larry Dillard Poole |
| 1997 : | Larry Dillard Poole |
| 1996 : | David Kenneth Thompson |
| 1995 : | Thomas Alexander "Tommy" Farr, Jr |
| 1994 : | Robert Vincent "Bob" Wylie, Sr |
| 1993 : | Richard Norman "Dick" Shannon |
| 1992 : | Edward Arthur "Ed" Radatz, Sr |
| 1991 : | |
| 1990 : | Thomas Alexander "Tommy" Farr, Jr |
| 1989 : | Samuel Kendrick "Sam" Price |
| 1988 : | Irvin Charles "Bud" Schooler |
| 1987 : | Donald Hiram "Don" Anderson * |
| 1986 : | Robert Vincent "Bob" Wylie, Sr |
| 1985 : | Richard Norman "Dick" Shannon |
| 1984 : | Donald Hiram "Don" Anderson * |
| 1983 : | Henry C. Baell, Jr. * |
| 1982 : | Robert Alton Webb |
| 1981 : | Robert Franklin "Frank" Burnette |
| 1980 : | Richard Norman "Dick" Shannon |
| 1979 : | Robert Derrell "Bob" White * |
| 1978 : | Douglas H. Hoskins ** |
| 1977 : | Robert Vincent "Bob" Wylie, Sr |
| 1976 : | William Allen Howe |
| 1975 : | Arthur Lee "Art" Martin |
| 1974 : | William H. Dickson |
| 1973 : | Jesse Clifton Hartley, Jr |
| 1972 : | Paul M. Grebe, Jr. |
| 1971 : | Lewis Eugene Haynes |
| 1970 : | James Leroy Robinson, Sr |
| 1969 : | Alfred Coard Warrington, IV |
| 1968 : | Albert P. Hornbuckle, Jr. |
| 1967 : | Emery D. Poole |
| 1966 : | William H. Dickson |
| 1965 : | Amos A. Tanner, Sr. |
| 1964 : | Jesse Clifton Hartley, Jr |
| 1963 : | Jewell Delyn McCall |
| 1962 : | Robert C. "Bob" Irwin, Jr. |
| 1961 : | Travis M. Crawford |
| 1960 : | Roy Augustus Causey, Jr |
| 1959 : | Ralph Waldo Ross |
| 1958 : | William R. Phillips * |
| 1957 : | Marvin Ollendorf, Jr |
| 1956 : | Robert Wood Harris |
| 1955 : | George W. Moore, Jr. |
| 1954 : | James Matthew Lyle, Jr |
| 1953 : | Henry T. Avery |
| 1952 : | Arthur B. Keith |
| 1951 : | Frank H. Griggs |
| 1950 : | Andrew Jackson "Jack" Kelly |
| 1949 : | Warren H. Alday |
| 1948 : | Elmer R. Moss * |
| 1947 : | Julian H. Wolf |
| 1946 : | Raymond Vincent Guyton, Sr |
| 1945 : | Ira R. Huffaker |
| 1944 : | John L. Newman |
| 1943 : | John C. Hutchinson |
| 1942 : | Thomas C. Barry * |
| 1941 : | William C. Burnett |
| 1940 : | Edward Ambrose Ryder, Sr. |
| 1939 : | Franklin C. Wilson |
| 1938 : | W. Eugene Callahan * |
| 1937 : | John N. Patrick |
| 1936 : | Preston B. Rowland * |
| 1935 : | Earl J. Sunkes |
| 1934 : | H. Eugene Craig |
| 1933 : | P. W. Hollingshead |
| 1932 : | Edward H. Anchors |
| 1931 : | Dr. J. Hiram Kite |
| 1930 : | Charles A. Peacock |
| 1929 : | Oliver J. Huie |
| 1928 : | Maynard B. Smith |
| 1927 : | Hervey W. Reese |
| 1926 : | J. Walter LeCraw |
| 1925 : | Charles S. Kingsberry |
| 1924 : | Robert H. Jones |
| 1923 : | Bartis E. Goodman |
| 1922 : | Sam H. Hill |
| 1921 : | George T. Bush |
| 1920 : | *** |
| 1919 : | W. Eugene Harrington |
| 1918 : | Middleton Samuel "Sam" Johnson * |
| 1917 : | S. Burney Naff |
| 1916 : | Elzie B. Thomas |
| 1915 : | Frank C. Everett |
| 1914 : | George S. Sparks |
| 1913 : | Owen S. Lair |
| 1912 : | Eugene C. Perkins |
| 1911 : | Kendall Weisiger |
| 1910 : | Paul P. Reese |
| 1909 : | Macon C. LaHatt |
| 1908 : | C. Perry Taylor |
| 1907 : | Dr. DeLos Lemuel Hill |
| 1906 : | Alonzo H. Johnson |
| 1905 : | Chris H. Essig |
| 1904 : | Frank T. Irwin |
| 1903 : | Augustus H. Esterly |
| 1902 : | Henry M. Wood |
Brethren with name italicized have been received into the Celestial Lodge.
An asterisk (*) indicates the PM has dimitted.
Two asterisks (**) indicates the PM was suspended.
Three asterisks (***) indicates the PM was expelled.